Contesting a Will After Probate

After the death of someone who has made a Will, a Grant of Probate is issued which gives one or more individuals the legal authority to administer the estate of the deceased. These individuals are known as the executors (or Personal Representatives) and they have the legal authority to distribute the assets of the deceased.

In many cases, people will want advice on contesting a Will after probate and this is where seeking the advice of a professional legal firm, dedicated to providing the best advice on how to challenge a Will, is essential.

Once Probate has been issued, there are certain time limits on contesting a will that need to be considered.

What are the grounds for contesting a will after a Grant of Probate?

There are many grounds for contesting a Will after probate:-

• Lack of Testamentary Capacity – where a claimant believes that the Testator (the legal term for an individual who has made a Will) may not have had the mental capacity to make a Will. This could be a result of the Testator suffering from dementia and/or because he/she was under the influence of painkillers or medicines that impacted on their judgement
• Coercion – where a Testator was coerced or influenced into making a will
• Fraud – where a will has been forged (and/or not actually signed by the Testator)
• The Will has not been properly executed (signed by the Testator in front of two witnesses who sign in front of him/her and each other)
• You are a near relative or dependant of the Testator (child, spouse, dependant or partner) and require or believe you are entitled to financial provision from his/her estate (NOTE: this type of claim MUST be brought within 6 months of the Grant of Probate)

The estate has not been properly administered or distributed

This is a common problem in Will dispute claims. Typically the Executor (or Personal Representative/Trustee appointed by the Will) has kept some estate money for himself, wrongly paid out estate money to a beneficiary, failed to pay out estate money from an estate under the terms of a Trust set up by the Will (for instance to a beneficiary on reaching 18 or 21) and failed to keep proper accounts or records. In some cases your claim might lie against a professional Executor or Trustee (bank, Solicitor or Accountant). We may be required to pursue the Executor/Trustee/Personal Representative for breach of Trust and/or to replace him or her.

NOTE 1 : this type of claim may have a time limit of 6 years from the date of the breach or Grant of Probate. You should seek advice on it as quickly as possible.

NOTE 2: the Trustee usually has a duty to furnish a beneficiary with accounts and to act properly and in good faith. He or she may incur a personal liability if they fail in this duty

NOTE 3: whilst the Trustee/Personal Representative/Executor can charge if they are acting in a professional capacity; if they are not acting in such a capacity their ability to do so is much more restricted

Risks

It is usually better to dispute a Will before probate has been granted simply because afterwards, the estate can be distributed. However, leaving this aside, if you seek to stop the Grant of Probate (by entering a Caveat), there is a risk of Court proceedings being issued against you whereas this is not the case after the Grant of Probate (it will be up to you to issue proceedings if applicable at that stage if you cannot resolve your dispute over the Will).

How significant a risk will arise after the Grant of Probate (of the estate being distributed) depends on the circumstances. Usually (but not necessarily so) a letter of claim and the threat of proceedings will be sufficient to prevent unnecessary distribution before your will dispute has been resolved. However, it is possible to seek an injunction to prevent distribution in the appropriate circumstances and it may of course be possible to recover estate money that has been distributed before your claim has finished.

NOTE 4: you must not enter a Caveat to prevent the distribution of the estate if you are not contesting the validity of the Will but are bringing a claim for financial provision from the estate (under section 2 of the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.

Confused and requiring more information?

Please don’t hesitate to contact us for a free and confidential chat. Our telephone number appears above (0203 322 5103).There will naturally be many different reasons why you may wish to contest a will after probate so please do not hesitate to contact us to discuss your situation and allow us to gauge the possibility of successfully resolving your claim under a no win no fee arrangement.